One of the best reasons for visiting Cape May is sampling fresh seafood from the area’s local restaurants. With so many good restaurants to choose from, we’ve gathered up a few of our favorites for a list of where to get fresh seafood in Cape May.
Lobster House
Ask anyone and they’ll tell where to get fresh seafood in Cape May is at the Lobster House. A local favorite, the Lobster House has proudly served their patrons the freshest seafood and exceptional dining experience for over four generations. Sample something from their menu or step outside to the Raw Bar dining room where you can try everything from raw clams and oysters to hard shell crabs and lobster.
Or take something to go at their fresh Fish Market. Here you will find a wide variety of the freshest seafood in Southern New Jersey. Choose from the fresh fare that lands by way of their own commercial fishing boats or freshly imported seafood from all over the world.
During the warmer months, enjoy the full dining experience with dinner on their casual dockside with beautiful waterfront views.
Fish and Fancy Seafood Take Out
No need to get fancy at this casual seafood joint. Coined “the local’s favorite seafood”, Fish and Fancy prides itself on fresh seafood and preparing their food with only the best high-quality ingredients. Take it to go or eat there and enjoy fresh scallops, lobster tails, flounder, crabs, clams, and so much more. Choose from a daily “blackboard” specials like fried fish & chips, broiled grouper, and grilled pineapple teriyaki salmon. Trust us, your taste buds will thank you.
Cape May Fish Market
Get hooked on fresh seafood at the Cape May Fish Market. Inspired by the plentiful seafood Cape May has to offer, you will have an extensive seafood menu to choose from. People can’t get enough of their fresh fish, clam chowder, and lobster rolls. Located in the Washington St. Mall, it offers a convenient location to shops and local accommodations like the Southern Mansion.
H & H Seafood
Nobody does fresh Blue Claw crabs better than H & H Seafood. What started as an outlet for their commercial boat operation, H & H Seafood began offering live crabs and local lobsters. Today their seafood offerings extend beyond where they started with live crabs and lobsters, fresh clams, oysters, shrimp, scallops, and fish.
Grab your seafood to go or stay and dine on their waterfront dock for some of the best views in Cape May.
Oyster Bay Restaurant and Bar
Who doesn’t love a little surf n’ turf? That is exactly what you will find at Oyster Bay Restaurant and Bar. Famous for their fresh seafood and steak, Oyster Bay Restaurant offers a wide variety of menu selections like seared scallops, filet mignon with crabmeat, and oyster bay Jambalaya. Be sure to also pair your meal with one of their martinis from the “martini madness menu.”
Be sure to check for seasonal closures and openings as some Cape May restaurants close or offer limited availability in the winter and into early spring.
Cape May lodging
No matter where you pull up a seat for dinner, make Southern Mansion your home base for your next Cape May vacation. Our bed and breakfast offers complimentary daily breakfast, private bathrooms, and luxurious Victorian-themed rooms. Be sure to always check our monthly specials and book direct with us to receive the best rate! We hope to see you soon!
